Why Umno’s reign must end

WHEN the Alliance coalition under prime minister Tunku Abdul Rahman assumed power as our first government on August 31, 1957, Dwight Eisenhower was US president, Nikita Khrushchev and Mao Zedong the supremo of the Soviet Union and China, Harold MacMillan the prime minister of the UK, Jawaharlal Nehru the prime minister of India and Sukarno the president of Indonesia. 

In the decades that followed, the US president and the UK prime minister have rotated between their two major political parties. 

Nehru’s Congress party lost power at the ballot box in 1977. Sukarno was overthrown in a coup in 1965.  The Soviet Union collapsed in 1991. 

The only political party among these randomly selected nations still in power today is Mao’s Communist Party of China.

Yet in Malaysia, 13 general elections and 60 years later, that coalition known since 1974 as Barisan Nasional is still in power. 

The Umno-led coalition is the political grouping with the greatest longevity in the world, ruling continuously and without a break for 60 years.

It follows that all the ills that plague the nation, whether politically, economically, socially or otherwise, are the result of Umno’s stranglehold over the nation.

They are principally to be blamed for racial and religious polarisation, endemic corruption, centralisation of power in the office of the prime minister, the lack of independent, impartial institutions intended to act as checks and balances over the power and influence of the executive, the increase of Putrajaya’s influence to the detriment of the 14 states, and so on.

I shall in the coming weeks describe in some detail how one party’s rule for more than half a century is gravely injurious to our welfare. 

Just imagine the Conservative party ruling the UK since 1957 or the Republican party providing the 11 presidents after Eisenhower. Well, one cannot imagine such a scenario.  So why should it be acceptable to us?

So, the foremost reason for a change of government in the 14th general election is that Malaysians must be freed at last from the clutches of Umno. Sixty years is surely sufficient for any one political coalition to rule any country. Enough is enough.

Although the Alliance had three component parties and BN has 14, it is commonly accepted that the reins of power have always been in the hands of Umno, with its president automatically becoming prime minister. 

Major policies are made and decisions taken by Umno, sometimes even at its Supreme Council meetings. Each of the 13 other component parties knows its subordinate place in the BN hierarchy. The political reality is that for 60 years, Umno has dominated public space in Malaysia.

For a party that was established in 1946, Umno has only had seven presidents in its 71-year history. Four of its president left the party after leaving office. 

Onn Jaafar, Tunku, Hussein Onn and Dr Mahathir Mohamad not only resigned from Umno but joined parties opposing it. It is as if they only discovered the true nature of Umno after they left office. Abdul Razak Hussein died as its president. The only former president who continues to support it after his resignation is Abdullah Ahmad Badawi.

This year’s general election must, therefore, be treated by voters as a referendum on Umno’s continuous and unbroken rule since Merdeka. 

How has it managed public finances; administered schools and hospitals; arranged sales of national assets like public utilities, roads and railways to the private sector in lopsided deals against the public interest; deprived space to minorities, critics and dissenters, and so on. 

It should be judged on its political and economic governance of the nation. How has it fared? What about nepotism, cronyism, patronage and leakages?

Seen in this perspective, the focus must be on the actual governance by Umno for six decades, rather than considering the opposition, and whether Pakatan Harapan would be able to govern as a federal government. 

Well, no opposition party or coalition has so far been entrusted with national governance, and so it doesn’t have a track record to defend. 

Governing the states is not a real comparison because the states have little power and influence over matters that affect our daily life, apart from local government issues. 

But even if one were to measure the performances of the Penang and Selangor governments since 2008, objectively speaking, they have performed creditably, and can be trusted to govern federally.

But I suggest that the focus should be on those who have held federal power to defend their track record, and be judged by such governance. Hence, the spotlight must be turned on Umno. – January 18, 2018.

* Tommy Thomas is an advocate and solicitor.

* This is the opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of The Malaysian Insight. Article may be edited for brevity and clarity.

Sign up or sign in here to comment.


  • Nothing changes if nothing changes !

    Posted 6 years ago by Malaysia Forward · Reply

  • Great insight and I agree. UMNO has done more damage due to greed and worst of all incompetent! Leaders has no style and of low quality in moral and public handling

    Posted 6 years ago by Crishan Veera · Reply

  • I must salute the writer for his well reasoned and fearless opinion. It is such brave, independent and committed souls who truly care for a progressive future. Syabas Sir.

    Posted 6 years ago by JD Lovrenciear · Reply

  • I live un British Columbia, Canada
    We had the liberal government for the past 16 years
    Last year we dumped it and voted the left leaning ndp government

    With the change, many tolls on bridges were abolished
    Medical insurance was reduced by half
    The poor were better looked after

    What I am trying to say is it is time to dump umno
    They are too arrogant, greedy, self serving,
    They had power and greed for too Long

    If the opposition comes into government, a lot of good will come to Malaysia
    Pap in Singapore prefer to work with umno for their own selfish reason
    They know umno is corrupt and Malaysia will never able to compete
    If ph comes into power, it is a different ball game for pap

    Posted 6 years ago by Harytan456 Tan · Reply

  • We have seen leaders trying hard to keep the nation up on par with the world, wanting to be a developed nation. There exists the baggage of racism, corruption, cronyism and extremism associated with UMNO that drags down the feet of progress. Only with UMNO and BN gone, the appearance of a cosmopolitan nation is possible.

    Posted 6 years ago by Tanahair Ku · Reply