LTTE suspect tells court of abuse during police questioning


Bede Hong

B. Subramaniam (left) and A. Kalaimughilan, who have been charged with LTTE-related offences, at the Kuala Lumpur court complex this morning. Subramaniam was arrested on October 13. – The Malaysian Insight pic by Najjua Zulkefli, December 5, 2019.

A LIBERATION Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) suspect today testified on the alleged abuse he suffered at the hands of police during questioning two months ago.

Restaurant owner B. Subramaniam had his statement taken at the federal police headquarters after his arrest on October 13 for possessing materials, including a video, linked to the now-defunct terror group.

“When I was in the investigating room, there were four people. One of the men was wearing a silver bracelet and he kicked a water bottle. He was a big man,” the 57-year-old told Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court judge Azura Alwi.  

Subramaniam, who was dressed in a white shirt and uncuffed before taking the witness stand, spoke in Tamil.

“The officer had a cigarette in one hand, while another officer wrote things down.

“The room was small and air-conditioned. There was water on the floor, and they asked me to mop it up.

“They told me, ‘We are the kings here. We are not your workers. The walls are covered with blood, and don’t make us do that to you. Do you know, there have been people beaten up and thrown into the bush?’

“The officer who wrote things down told me that he came from Sarawak especially for this, and warned that if I did not cooperate with him, my family would be arrested and investigated.

“He said if I was beaten in the middle of the road and shot, police would find it hard to find me because I had many enemies.”

Subramaniam said he was questioned over a few days about a video, in which he is alleged to have used the word “pengganas” (terrorist).

“The officer who was writing was forcing me to confess and every day he used the word ‘pengganas’,” he said.

He said he was forced to sign several documents.

Subramaniam said he was told he would be jailed 30 years, but upon his confession, the police would work to have the jail term reduced to less than five years.

“The man with the silver bracelet told me that he has a relative in jail. He will make sure that I get a shorter jail sentence – less than five years and that perhaps… I could be out in three years.

During his questioning by police, Subramaniam said two officers would smoke and another two would use their vaping devices.

“Because the room was small, I could not breathe and I needed water. I looked at the cigarette box. The officer asked me why was I looking at the box and he told me he would slap me.”

Subramaniam said he was kept in isolation for a day. He added that medical officers checked on him thrice and they asked him whether he was beaten up.

Sumbramaniam told the court he was never physically assaulted by anyone.

“None of the investigating officers beat me up physically and they only mentally tortured me to confess about a video where I support terrorists. I don’t support terrorists. That is all.”

Azura asked him about his physical condition when he was examined by the doctor. Subramaniam said he was examined without his clothes three times during the 20 days he was detained.

“So you were not totally naked (bogel terus)? Nothing on?” asked the judge.

“Yes, the warden asked me to lower my pants to my knees,” said Subramaniam, adding that he was examined after he was questioned by the investigating officers.

“You said you were not physically assaulted…. So what was the mental torture you mentioned? Can you describe the mental torture you experienced?”

Subramaniam replied: “Asking me to confess that I support terrorists. I was placed in an air-conditioned room (for two days) that was cold. Breathing in the cigarette smoke non-stop.”

“If I didn’t confess, they (said) they would go to my house and arrest my family members and investigate them for something similar. After I was arrested, my fourth son was also asked to kneel beside me. This is the mental torture that I was speaking of. I was placed in an isolated room also. That is all.”

Subramaniam said he could not identify the man with the silver bracelet, adding that he had asked for their identities up to three times.

His sworn testimony was then read out to him before he signed it.

Subramaniam was represented by S. Selvam. 

Another suspect, scrap metal collector A. Kalaimughilan, 28, who was also in the dock today, will testify tomorrow on alleged ill-treatment by the police.

Over a dozen relatives and supporters turned up at the public gallery today.

Lawyer M. V. Yoges, representing Kalaimughilan, previously told the court that her client was ill-treated at Sungai Buloh Prison as he was not given a pillow and mattress to sleep on.

The duo have not lodged police reports on their complaints. Azura may call the investigating officers involved to respond to the allegations against them. She is empowered to examine whether an offence has occurred under Section 133 of the Criminal Procedure Code.

The hearing continues. – December 5, 2019.


Sign up or sign in here to comment.


Comments


  • Is this why the police are so terrified of the IPCMC?

    Posted 4 years ago by Arul Inthirarajah · Reply

  • The deep state is frightening and must be dealt with promptly by the parliament, failing which, it is bye bye for Pakatan in GE15.

    Posted 4 years ago by Tanahair Ku · Reply

  • Deep state sustained by people with deep pockets.

    Posted 4 years ago by CD E · Reply

  • Some serious issues with our so called protectors.

    Posted 4 years ago by CD E · Reply

  • Hahaha...liar

    Posted 4 years ago by Ty Tiko · Reply

    • I think we have a pretty good idea of who is lying. Those who are afraid of the IPCMC or those who welcome it? The answer is obvious.

      Posted 4 years ago by Arul Inthirarajah · Reply

  • The excuse the this new government gives is that the deep state is behind all these arrests , detention without a trial-the case being heard by a single Judge with no jury.
    A system that is illegal in international law and non-compliance with international human rights norms-this has been around for decades in Malaysia-decades!!
    It was with the legitimate expectation that this new government albeit with a lose coalition will bring forward the country to a period of reformation and democratization.
    A close study of this new government clearly shows that this deep state defence is a 'blatant lie', and not believable. If at all, the deep state is within Pakatan Harapan (PH).
    Dr Mahathir Mohamed once again has regained his dictatorial powers to do all and sundry. It is shocking despite international and domestic requests to repatriate a known terrorist ( one who has not only berated the Chinese and Indian community, purportedly incited terrorist attacks, money laundrying among other charges) is invited and praised by this government albeit vicariously.
    DR M does not need anybody's approval to do anything. Cabinet members who ranted and raved, condemned, cried, screamed about the ISA alleging the BN government is committing human rights violations is now silently acquiescence in this illegal arrests. On example of DR M 'spower is the CJ thanking and appreciating the PM for honoring the separation of powers. Is this a joke. That is the law, no need to kowtow to the PM.
    This law was supposed to be repealed. I am ashamed to listen to all the Non-Malay, and Malay ( a word which is a policy of segregation adopted by DR M) lawyers now in the cabinet argued then in the very courts about this draconian legislation. Today, like the late Karpal singh would say are like "mice" collecting taxpayer monies.
    Clearly, we need more Malay voices screaming out for the repeal of this legislation. Why? One day, you will be arrested by the very same legislation for speaking out.
    Malaysians are now already worried about the PH apparatus of security overlooking people who speak out exercising the most fundamental right of fee speech. Our only hope is Anwar Ibrahim, who was beaten by the DIGP-he knows the brutality of the police. We need him to take over in the next few months.

    Posted 4 years ago by Sotong Jimmy · Reply