Can Pakatan make a comeback?


SOMEONE just asked me: “Is there a chance for Dr Mahathir and Anwar to take over Putrajaya from Muhyiddin Yassin if there is a snap election within the next 18 months?” 

My answer was a bold “No”. There are several reasons why.  

 1. The relationship between Dr Mahathir Mohamad and Anwar Ibrahim not perceived to be cordial. Their media statements and public outlook show their glaring differences.

 2. The continuous belief that the DAP shadow is overwhelming and commanding Pakatan Harapan has caused discomfort in the larger Malay community, especially in the suburban and rural areas.

 3. The younger generation who will play a vital role in the next election is neither interested nor feeling connected to the reform agenda linked to Anwar and PKR.

 4. The Covid-19 pandemic gives an added advantage to Perikatan Nasional which is pouring out the incentives for the people and the economy even though businesses are still bleeding and a stitch here and there is not addressing the criticality. Cash in hand in the next 12 months is more important than making Dr Mahathir or Anwar the next prime minister.

 5. The Najib factor. Whether we like it or not the bitter truth is this man still holds significant weight in the political game. The bashing song that Dr Mahathir keeps singing has had its day. It is definitely not an evergreen number. And now he once again wants to play the same tune. It will not work.  I have said many times that the “against Najib tune” will backfire one day.

 6. Whichever party helms the  government must have the Malay unity agenda as its top priority.  On this note Dr Mahathir has failed this time.  He has sent mixed signals to the community.  One day he says the Malays are capable and the next day he says they are lazy. The younger generation will not buy that anymore. In the short 22 months it was in power, PH was seen to be undecided on the Malay unity agenda and it gave Umno and PAS an opening over which to form an alliance.  Obviously others in Bersatu realised that an Umno-PAS tie-up and the continued alliance of Bersatu with DAP would eventually cause Bersatu to be shunned by the Malay community.  

7. PKR is fast losing its shine and even its relevance. As it is a multiracial party, it can never champion any race based agenda. This compounded by the fact that just like DAP, it has been largely run by one family. It becomes harder for it to not only keep the current support but also to attract new and fresh faces. It has no real agenda anymore as people view it to have only a single objective since its leader returned to action. The reformation mantra no longer resonates especially with the younger generation.

8. It was Dr Mahathir himself who brought down his government.  No matter however he wants to justify his actions, none of them have been endorsed in totality and collectively by PH.This is important if PH wants to impress the masses. PKR, DAP, Amanah and Warisan have thus far stayed in the grey area on his justification for his resignation. What is more baffling is that he remained interim prime minister knowing very well that it only meant one thing: that a new prime minister will be appointed by the Agong. So why all the whining now? What did he expect to happen when he single handedly removed his cabinet? Will the public want to once again put the baton in his and his team’s handd? He had rather dropped it than pass it on when he had the chance.

Though some may not agree with my take – it is not one that I myself prefer – unfortunately the reality can be extremely bitter. – June 7, 2020.

* Narinder Pal reads The Malaysian Insight.
 

* This is the opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of The Malaysian Insight. Article may be edited for brevity and clarity.


Sign up or sign in here to comment.


Comments


  • Whats the hurry? IMO, just wait till GE15.

    By then, PN will collapse by itself with its numerous problems, both internally and externally.

    PH retaking the government now will be committing suicide. Can it overcome the COVID-19 crisis and the subsequent labour and financial and economic crises within less than three years when they are globally interconnected? Please remember people vote according to how they feel at that particular moment and it is not predictably good for the foreseeable future.

    Posted 6 years ago by Malaysian First · Reply

  • What most baffling thing that is happening right now is that PH supporters didn't don't get, it was Tun who shuts down PH and not Najin or Muhyiddin!

    Another shocking thing is that why DAP is still playing to Tun's tune?

    Is Power is more important than principle?

    Posted 6 years ago by Jonest Wong · Reply

    • Hamzah said he was tasked (by Tun) to UNDERMINE the support for DAP. It was beautifully executed.

      Mazlee introduced "Khat" and LKS was pelted with rotten eggs as a result!!!!!

      LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

      Posted 6 years ago by Malaysian First · Reply

  • Yes, it will come back. I am all behind PH. If not PH, who else???

    Posted 6 years ago by Tanahair Ku · Reply

  • PH need to overhaul. It will be a different ball game in 3 years time. There will be more young voters. Their needs will be different and they want to see a leader that they can relate to them. At the moment Anwar doesnt appeal to them. Perhaps Rafizi should come back to helm PKR now that the traitors are basking in glory in another party.

    Posted 6 years ago by Elyse Gim · Reply

  • To PH supporters, RIP, the younger generation wouldnt go for any Party headed owned by a family, just like a rojak business, hahaha

    Posted 6 years ago by Ty Tiko · Reply

  • M have already expressed his dislike of anwar .That is why he refused to hand over PM as agreed earlier but only needed him to push his agenda. As long as anwar is in, his hope for his son to be PM is dashed out. It is obvious that all shud be able to see M is only interested to get back at Muh as he previously did to Najib. Malaysia need a PM who cares for the country and not politics!

    Posted 6 years ago by Jos Koh · Reply

  • Wrong lah. Remember Otto von Bismarck said Politics is the art of the possible. Anything can happen from now.

    Posted 6 years ago by Lam Buyao · Reply

  • RIP Pakatan, out of my mind to know from revelation that Pakatan ministers were full of lies & corrupt too.

    Posted 6 years ago by Ty Tiko · Reply

  • PH will not garner enough votes to take over the government, because they are not willing to let off their Power to new blood generation. Anwar should allow his Daughter to do more PR, LKS, D.M team up as Adviser and allow New Blood to go round and canvass that the Party was for all Malaysian. Covid19 is very good for them to start their campaign work now and let the Public trust them

    Posted 6 years ago by Albert Chiu · Reply

  • PH already cameback as opposition. PH was so good while being opposition but so unperformed as government.
    - LGE can get quotation 1/10 of the price he paid for AES/AWAS camera.
    - Anwar would cut IPP reserved while he was Permatang Pauh MP but do nothing while in PD.

    Posted 6 years ago by Johari Sulaiman · Reply