Stop blaming nature and take responsibility

SAHABAT Alam Malaysia (SAM) calls on the Kedah government to take responsibility for the Baling floods and the devastation that resulted in the deaths of three persons and the loss of homes for hundreds of others.

SAM is appalled by the response given by Kedah Menteri Besar Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor, who once again rubbished logging as a possible cause for the massive gush of water from the streams in Gunung Inas. Sanusi, according to media reports, attributed the cause to a “waterhead problem”, with the accumulation of water upstream following the rain, similar to the Gunung Jerai tragedy last year.

The waterhead phenomenon cannot be a convenient excuse when we see pictures of large amounts of trees and logs washed down with the gushing of silt-laden waters. Also, there is a video circulating widely on social media which shows a company promoting its musang king durian plantations in the Gunung Inas area, involving the massive clearings of forests.

The menteri besar must have seen such videos and explain if they are fake or if there is some truth in them, because the credibility of the Kedah government is at stake.

Sanusi’s response in blaming Mother Nature as the cause for the severe floods is most irresponsible, when it defies logic and common sense that the upper reaches of Gunung Inas are not in a pristine state and not free from land disturbances. The land clearings that are ongoing may not be for logging, but surely, it cannot be said that nothing is happening in the area.

We are also equally outraged by the response from the Energy and Natural Resources Minister Takiyuddin Hassan who also said that no active logging activities had been reported in the Gunung Inas forest reserve and that the floods could have been due to a water surge phenomenon, echoing the sentiments of the menteri besar.

The Takiyuddin’s assertion that 5,000 trees have been planted in a 52ha area as part of reforestation efforts in the area is no comfort to us when such efforts are insignificant, compared to the hundreds or thousands of hectares which are cleared for plantations or other purposes.

In order to come clean on the matter and to regain public confidence, SAM once again calls on the Kedah government to hold a public inquiry to get to the root of the matter, both in the case of the Baling floods and the Gunung Jerai tragedy.

Clearly, there is more to these incidences than meets the eye, and if we are to avert another tragedy of this kind. Such an inquiry is needed to ascertain what exactly is going on in the state of Kedah in this regard and what measures and gaps need to be addressed with urgency.

Simply blaming Mother Nature is not going to work any longer, as the intensity and frequency of such intense rainfall due to climate change will be a recurring problem.

Also, it is not enough for the federal government to just be seen as providing aid and cash relief as such band aid measures are not going to prevent further disasters from happening, not only in Kedah but in all other states, where the rampant clearing of forests for all kinds of purposes including for logging, plantations and mining activities are allowed.

It is time to act with responsibility and prevent further tragedies. Let’s not wait for more disasters! – July 6, 2022.

* Meenakshi Raman is president of Sahabat Alam Malaysia.

* This is the opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of The Malaysian Insight. Article may be edited for brevity and clarity.

Sign up or sign in here to comment.


  • Otherwise they had to blame the Almighty.

    What do idiots know? CAT? Not in this government!

    Posted 1 month ago by Malaysian First · Reply

  • "Water head", "Water surge", "Kepala air" are not supernatural happenings. What all these words mean is simply that there was heavy rain up in the hills, no different from the heavy rain that we experience in lowland areas, e.g. towns.
    The problem is that all the trees, plants, shrubs, grass that covered the soil have been removed and the bare soil exposed to the direct 'hit' of heavy rain that rapidly washes layers of the barren soil away and into the rivers. In forested hills, flow of heavy rain water is firstly slowed by the trees & plants that cover the soil, and secondly the water gets into the soil to be held by the root systems that act like a sponge. If the rain is very, very heavy, some water will run off and might cause a little flooding, but nothing like the disastrous floods with such heavily silt laden water.
    So the authorities, caught with their pants down, should not blame God. That is what they are doing when they talk of "kepala air". Who authorised the rape of the Baling Hills? Who carried out the rape?

    Posted 1 month ago by Ravinder Singh · Reply

  • Meenakshi, in Bolehland it's the works of Almighty...... No human with cow brains takes responsibility. That's it......only GOD saves this country.....opps. on the contrary.....GOD?

    Posted 1 month ago by Crishan Veera · Reply