Covid-19 not an excuse to crack down on illegals

IN response to the statement by senior minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob that illegal immigrants identified in areas under enhanced movement-control order (EMCO) will be placed in detention centres after the order is lifted, interim executive director of Amnesty International Malaysia Preethi Bhardwaj said:

“The EMCO is meant to slow the spread of Covid-19, not act as a tool to round up undocumented migrants. This is an outrageous decision on the part of the authorities as placing people in detention exposes them to increased risk of contracting the virus.

“Detention solely for immigration purposes is only allowed in the most exceptional of circumstances. During a global public health crisis, detention solely for migration-related reasons is unjustifiable.

“Immigration detention centres in Malaysia are well known for their poor conditions. In a time of a pandemic, placing undocumented migrants in overcrowded and filthy detention centres and so-called special prisons will only accelerate the spread of Covid-19.

“It is even more concerning that Taman Murni in Selayang is one of the places undocumented migrants will reportedly be rounded up.

“This area houses many Rohingya refugees who are at risk of being deported back to Myanmar where they face ethnic cleansing by the Myanmar government.

“Rather than locking people up, the authorities should seek to process migrant claims while ensuring people’s liberty. Healthcare goods, services, and facilities must be provided to everyone regardless of nationality. This extends to the undocumented immigrants and refugees who are particularly vulnerable in the pandemic.”


On April 20, Ismail Sabri said eight areas in Kuala Lumpur would be placed under the EMCO.

Under the EMCO, all residents and visitors within the area are forbidden from exiting their homes during the order.

Amnesty International and others, including the National Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam), have documented inhumane conditions of detention and human rights abuses that take place in immigration detention centres around the country.

According to Suhakam, between 2015 and 2017, there were more than 100 cases of deaths of detainees.

Many of the casualties included Rohingya refugees. To date, the government has failed to respond adequately to concerns raised by international human rights organisations and Suhakam. – April 30, 2020.

* Amnesty International is a civil society organisation, headquartered in the United Kingdom, focusing on human rights.

* This is the opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of The Malaysian Insight.

Sign up or sign in here to comment.


  • Why not? Make good use of EMCO to crack down not only illegals but the drug traffickers and human trafficking. Knock down all illegal activities during this Golden time bcos it's easier, safer and most effective to do it now.

    Posted 4 months ago by James Wong · Reply

  • If it's not now to take action, when else. Firm action must be taken against them EMCO or not.

    Posted 4 months ago by Chong min · Reply